This was the message which was the basis for my first post.
This server security certificate is not valid at this time. This may be caused by a misconfiguration or an attacker intercepting your connection.
Yes Bubbly, many people have had this problem. It is an issue for the web sites themselves. It was known well in advance that many site's SSL certificates would expire in November this year but despite that some did not renew and even for those that did our browsers may look for the old certificate and not seeing it label the site as untrustworthy or unsafe.
Here is a good article on the topic of Lets Encrypt certificates;
Some Mac and Android users experience website connection issues caused by expired Let's Encrypt certificates - gHacks Tech News
It's my understanding that there are a couple of ways this may be fixed. BUT in the above article Let's Encrypt released lists of platforms that may run into issues from September 30, 2021 onward (and those that should not). Included on this list (see article) are macOS before 10.12.1 so if you are running MacOS Mavericks 10.9.5 you may have an ongoing problem.
As previously mentioned with your device Bubbly, you could update to High Sierra 10.13.6
If your rather not do this there are a few suggested methods that
may help.
1. Clearing your browser cache and cookies.
2. Open Key Chain Access, Click
login in the left panel, then click
Certificates under "Category" in the left. Delete the certificate that's giving you trouble by right-clicking it and selecting
Delete.
3. Apparently it's also very important to check your system Time and Date are correct.
Lastly, let me say i'm running High Sierra on a 2010 Mac Book (white unibody model) and it works very well so I'm sure you would find the same with your 2012 iMac. Having said that, High Sierra is "unsupported" too but as a much later OS its capable of running browsers and apps that are.